Are Electric Planes Possible?
Log in
YouTube
by
akkayaecrin251
This episode of Real Engineering is brought to you by Brilliant, a problem solving website
that teaches you think like an engineer.
Over the past decade we have seen multiple industries looking to transition to renewable
fuel sources, and while we have been making huge strides in the production of renewable
energy, the technology required to allow every industry to use it has not kept pace. In theory
we could replace every coal burning power plant in the world in the morning, and manage
just fine, IF we had a reasonable way of storing that energy cost effectively and efficiently.
This energy storage dilemma is slowing our adoption of renewable energy, and one of the
industries this is most apparent is the aviation and aerospace industry. Elon Musk is running
around pushing electric vehicles and solar powered homes, yet every time a Falcon 9 launches
it burns 147 tonnes of fossil fuel. Boeing and Airbus are in a constant battle to create
the most fuel efficient plane, allowing their customers to save on ever increasing fuel
costs and increase their bottom line, yet they are still using kerosene, when energy
from the grid is cheaper.
So what gives? Why isn’t every industry on earth clawing at the prospect of transitioning
to renewable fuels? The aviation industry has one massive hurdle to overcome before
it can successful adopt renewable energy. The energy density of our storage methods.
Energy density is a measure of the energy we can harness from 1 kilogram of an energy
source. For kerosene, the fuel jet airliners use, that’s about 43 MJ/kg. Currently even
our best lithium ion batteries come in around 1 MJ/kg. Battery energy is over 40 times heavier
than jet fuel.
So why is this such a huge problem. A plane flies when lift equals the weight of the plane,
so when we increase the weight, we have to increase the lift, which requires more power.
Needing more power means we need more batteries, which increases the weight again. So are caught
in a catch 22 of design.
We could end the video there, but going by the demographic breakdown of this channel,
we can go a little deeper. To really understand why this is such a difficult problem, let’s
do some back of the envelope calculations to convert two planes, the Airbus a320 and
a small personal aircraft like a Cessna, to battery power. Ultimately, we want to know
the power requirements of flight and how it will draw on the energy supply of the battery.
Animation 5 The work-energy theorem tells us that Work
= F × ∆x, where delta x is the distance over which a force acts. Power is work per
unit time, so P equals work divided time. (Work/∆t). Inserting our equation for work
and we get an equation for power that equals Force multiplied by distance divided by time,
otherwise known as velocity. Here delta v is the velocity of whatever is getting worked
on, in this case it’s the air. When a plane is flying at a constant height, we know that
the the force of lift and the force of gravity are balanced. That means the upward force
of lift (Flift) has to be equal in magnitude to the downward pull of gravity, which equals
the mass of the plane multiplied by gravity So, the power required for lift equals the