HS1101 U1: Career cornerstones: Establishing a foundation for a career in healthcare.

( Introduction )

People strive to be “good,” to do the “right” thing, and to lead a “good life,” but where do such basic, familiar moral values as good and right originate? Throughout history, religious people have explained these ideas as revelations of divine command. Anthropologists, however, view morals as customs that govern social interactions, and because all cultures display such customs, interpret moral practices in terms of a survival function rooted in human nature. By contrast, many social and political thinkers emphasize that moral concepts result from social conventions or agreements that are subject to deliberation and change. Governments today often consult social scientists and health experts who empirically investigate what fosters or improves human life, health, and happiness. Where science informs law and policy, it helps define in a conventional sense what we mean by good and right. In particular, health science helps establish what is considered good for the health of populations and communities. Further below we will examine ethical theories prominent in health ethics that offer contrasting perspectives on the nature and basis of morality. We will also explore the impact of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) on patient confidentiality and the importance of consent in healthcare and research.

Ethical Theories

As used here, an ethical framework refers to a tool or approach for practically addressing ethical challenges that often includes a stepwise procedure. An ethical framework may rely heavily on just one ethical theory, but frameworks generally take a pragmatic approach that procedurally allows for using a variety of theories or principles as the issue or context demands. Whereas an ethical framework has a practical orientation, an ethical theory also addresses more fundamental questions, so-called “metaethical” questions. Does morality originate in divine command, human nature, or human convention? Is it essentially a habit, intuition, form of reasoning, or a quality or purpose of an action? An ethical theory will offer a distinct, coherent understanding of the source and nature of morality that will shape how one reasons about moral issues and determine which principles are most important. Two persons employing the same theory, however, will not necessarily reach the same conclusion about an ethical issue; much will depend on which aspects of the issue they deem most important and on how they weigh different factors. Nevertheless, because a particular ethical theory tends to favor certain principles or types of principles, using the same theoretical approach will lead to similar lines of reasoning and selection of principles.

The diversity of ethical theories does not imply their mutual opposition so much as points to the extensive range of the moral landscape and the need to illuminate its various contours. A helpful way of illuminating this landscape is to distinguish theories depending on whether they focus on the actor, the action, or the results of action. To illustrate this particular way of carving up the moral landscape, Table 5.1 describes some well-known ethical theories.

Aristotle’s virtue ethics is an ethical theory that focuses on the moral character of the actor or agent (Bartlett and Collins, 2011). Classic virtues are dispositions or stable patterns of behavior that lie between extremes of vice. Courage, for example, lies between the extremes of cowardice and foolhardiness in taking risks. Habit and practice are necessary to develop virtues whose possession we equate with good character and that equip a person to be effective in society or an organization. Because good character translates into virtuous action that others aspire to emulate, we tacitly invoke virtue ethics whenever we ask how an outstanding public figure or health leader would handle a situation. In a modern professional context, virtues also include the skills the profession has identified that lead to success in that profession and which professional education and training instill in practitioners. Once established, virtues readily become the standards of obligation and accountability to evaluate professional performance and function similarly to the rules and principles of duty discussed below. Holding public health institutions accountable for the professional competence of their employees illustrates virtue ethics (Public Health Leadership Society, 2002). More recently, the capabilities approach has exploited the potential of virtue ethics to guide decisions about policy or interventions in a way that goes beyond matters of professional training and responsibilities. This approach takes a broader developmental view of human agency and capacity building. It conceives health as a fundamental capability necessary for individuals to succeed in society, one in which many further capabilities depend (Sen, 2009; Ruger, 2010).

An ethical theory that focuses on action or, more properly, the rules governing action, is deontology. The word deontology comes from the ancient Greek word, deontos, which means duty. Because duties oblige us to obey rules that govern actions or conduct, they bind or constrain the will ahead of action. In judging whether an action is right or wrong, deontology ignores consideration of harmful or beneficial consequences and relies on these rules of duty to serve as the standard of judgment. People usually have rules of duty or obligation in mind when they speak of ethical standards or worry that standards are breaking down. Examples of these rules include religious commandments to honor parents, not lie, or not steal and rules of social interaction such as treating people fairly, doing them no harm, or respecting their rights. Rights often are said to stand in reciprocal relation to duties. Thus, the right to free speech presupposes a duty to respect the right of others to speak or the public health obligation to ensure conditions for maintaining health presupposes a right to health.

Deontology as a theory owes most to Immanuel Kant’s view of the “good will” and his closely linked account of autonomy. A person of morally good will does the right thing for its own sake, which means acting purely for the sake of duty. Duties are moral rules or laws that bind the will and limit the scope of action. For Kant, basing decision for one’s action solely on duty without regard to the potential good or bad consequences of the action is the only legitimate basis for moral action. Kant even goes so far as to say that “a free will and a will under moral laws are one and the same” (Gregor, Timmermann, and Korsgaard, 2012).

pression of autonomy, which may come as a surprise to those who equate autonomy with rational free choice or even just following one’s preferences without interference. However, the meaning of autonomy for Kant derives from its literal meaning in Greek, autos (self) and nomos (law); namely, self-legislating. Autonomy enacts from within the moral rules and principles that bind the will and guide action. However, not every self-originating impulse should be obeyed; only actions conceivable as universal laws morally bind the will. Morally laying down the law for oneself entails legislating for everyone, but universally legislating does not mean asserting one’s will over others. Nor does it mean that the ethical content of a moral law or duty is valid eternally and everywhere. Rather, it refers to the “categorical imperative” an unconditional requirement for an action to be moral. To qualify as a duty, a rule that commands action must apply to every rational person. Stealing, for example, could never qualify as a duty, because a situation where everyone steals from everyone else would undercut the one-sided advantage of stealing that the thief hopes to exploit. Although self-directed, autonomous action is necessarily other-regarding.

Kant maintains that the categorical imperative can be expressed in two other ways equivalent to universality, namely, “respect for humanity” and a “kingdom of ends” (Gregor, Timmermann, and Korsgaard, 2012). In each, this other-regarding dimension of autonomy is evident. Respecting humanity means never treating persons as mere means or objects but always treating them as ends, that is, regarding them as fellow autonomous agents. Autonomously agreeing on actions, interventions, or policies requires that decision-makers mutually consider and understand their reasons for action and be willing to abide by the rules derived from these reasons as laws they collectively impose upon themselves (O’Neill, 2002).

The idea of a fellowship of mutual consideration comes out most clearly in Kant’s concept of a kingdom of ends. This concept is really the ideal of a systematic union or commonwealth of autonomous individuals making laws that apply to everyone. This ideal presupposes that ethical deliberation places respect for others as ends, as autonomous agents, above self-interest. The core idea is that we only consider actions that could gain acceptance by a community in which all see themselves as sovereigns who lay down universal laws binding on themselves and others. The hope is that the body of law governing society progressively embodies this ideal. Such mutual regard in laying down the moral laws that will bind one’s actions differs significantly from insistence on noninterference with individual free choice, let alone with personal preferences. Conversely, the aspiration behind Kant’s view of autonomy harmonizes well with the public health obligation to address collective problems through collective action.

For utilitarianism, judging the rightness of an action depends on an estimation of its subsequent practical outcome or result rather than on its conformity to principles of duty. Utilitarianism considers the best ethical course of action that will result in the greatest net benefits over potential harm. A utilitarian approach underlies cost-benefit analyses that weigh an intervention’s costs (risks, harms, burdens, or disadvantages) against its benefits (advantages, utility, improvements, cost savings). In addition to its focus on consequences, utilitarianism is egalitarian, communitarian, and scientific in outlook. It is egalitarian in considering everyone’s benefit and equally weighting each person’s good, as opposed to privileging certain people. It is communitarian in attempting to increase benefits to society rather than individuals, seeking the “greatest good for the greatest number.” It endeavors to be scientific by quantifying harms and benefits, accounting for probability, and calculating net benefit. Calculating net benefits over harms is less problematic when relevant factors employ a common scale of measurement, for example, weighing the financial costs of treating a disease with the cost savings from preventing that disease. Comparing different outcomes (e.g., financial costs versus quality-adjusted life years) sometimes involves difficult judgments about the relative value of each outcome. Because the utilitarian approach seeks to determine and promote the collective good based on aggregate measures, it readily lends itself to justifying public health interventions.

Ethics and Morality

Although many use the terms ethics and morality interchangeably, we will distinguish the formal discipline of ethics from the common morality that guides everyday actions and behavior. Morality refers to a society’s shared, stable beliefs about what is good and bad, right and wrong. Through upbringing and socialization, each generation passes this common morality to the next. Common morality envelopes the individual like an ecosphere of shared customs, rules, and values. For most circumstances, people habitually rely on this common morality to guide their conduct, and it serves them well, just as standard practice generally serves professional practitioners well. Still, common morality can fall short where its rules conflict, where it inadequately illuminates novel moral problems, or where intense disagreement prevails among rival stakeholders. In such instances, the formal discipline of ethics offers a deliberate, systematic way of addressing troubling moral issues, conflicts, and dilemmas.

Ethics can assist in:

Recognizing ethical issues and distinguishing them from factual issues

Providing a vocabulary to systematically discuss ethics

Identifying appropriate ethical principles to guide action in a particular context

Using these principles to analyze actions in regard to their ethical acceptability

Understanding the competing moral claims and values of stakeholders

Designing alternative courses of action that incorporate these claims and values

Evaluating which alternative best fits a given context, all things considered

Establishing a procedurally just, transparent process for decision making

Justifying decisions regarding recommendations, policies, or interventions

Ethical Principles

Principles are general categories, rules, or guidelines that form the basis of a discipline. In ethics, there are various kinds of principles and many examples of each kind. The kinds include basic ethical categories (e.g., virtues, values, or rights), ethical commands or rules of conduct (e.g., not stealing, not harming, or treating others with respect ), and guidelines for weighing outcomes (e.g., achieving the greatest good for the greatest number, distributing burdens and benefits fairly, or properly proportioning benefit to harm). Ethical principles like justice or respect for autonomy are simultaneously values, ideals, and the basis for deriving rules of conduct. Such rules serve as ethical standards to evaluate past and pending actions, programs, and policy recommendations. When addressing complex or controversial issues or issues involving numerous stakeholders, many different principles can come into play. But because ethical decision-making depends on context (e.g., on local circumstances, community stakeholders, and decision-makers), no formula can determine the most relevant ethical principles. Nevertheless, most ethicists and practitioners working in a field would agree that certain principles, theories, or frameworks provide more helpful guidance for that field. Given the need for flexibility, some prefer to speak not of ethical principles but of “general moral considerations” that can provide guidance in healthcare practice (Childress et al., 2002). At any rate, a complex ethical challenge involving stakeholders with competing moral claims frequently demands consideration of a variety of ethical principles and theories to address the situation and justify a proposed intervention.

health information privacy rights

Patients feel that their health information is private and should be protected. That is why there is a federal law that sets rules for healthcare providers and health insurance companies about who can look at and receive their health information. This law, called the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), gives patients rights over their health information, including the right to get a copy of their information, make sure it is correct, and know who has seen it.

Patients can ask to see or get a copy of their medical records and other health information. If they want a copy, they may have to put a request in writing and pay for the cost of copying and mailing. In most cases, copies must be given to them within 30 days. Patients can ask to change any wrong information in their files or add information to their files if they think something is missing or incomplete. For example, if they and their hospital agree that the patient’s file has the wrong result for a test, the hospital must change it. Even if the hospital believes the test result is correct, they still have the right to have a disagreement noted in the file. In most cases, the file should be updated within 60 days.

By law, health information can be used and shared for specific reasons not directly related to care, like making sure doctors give good care, making sure nursing homes are clean and safe, reporting when the flu is in the area, or reporting as required by state or federal law. In many of these cases, a patient can find out who has seen their health information.

Patients can learn how their health information is used and shared by their doctor or health insurer. Generally, health information cannot be used for purposes not directly related to their care without their permission. For example, a patient’s doctor cannot give it to their employer, or share it for things like marketing and advertising, without their written authorization. Most patients probably received a notice telling them how their health information may be used on their first visit to a new healthcare provider or when they got new health insurance, but a patient can ask for another copy anytime.

Patients can let their providers or health insurance companies know if there is information they do not want to share. They can ask that their health information not be shared with certain people, groups, or companies. If they go to a clinic, for example, they can ask the doctor not to share their medical records with other doctors or nurses at the clinic. Patients can ask for other kinds of restrictions, but the doctors do not always have to agree to do what they ask, particularly if it could affect care. Finally, a patient can also ask their healthcare provider or pharmacy not to tell their health insurance company about the care they receive or drugs they take, if they pay for the care or drugs in full and the provider or pharmacy does not need to get paid by their insurance company.

Patients can ask to be reached somewhere other than home. They can make reasonable requests to be contacted at different places or in a different way. For example, they can ask to have a nurse call them at your office instead of their home or to send mail to them

Privacy, security, and electronic health records

Most healthcare providers are moving from paper records to electronic health records (EHRs) or they may be using EHRs already. EHRs allow providers to use information more effectively to improve the quality and efficiency of care, but EHRs will not change the privacy protections or security safeguards that apply to patients’ health information.

EHRs are electronic versions of paper charts in doctors’ or other healthcare providers’ offices. An EHR may include a patient’s medical history, notes, and other information about their health including their symptoms, diagnoses, medications, lab results, vital signs, immunizations, and reports from diagnostic tests such as x-rays. Providers are working with other doctors, hospitals, and health plans to find ways to share that information. The information in EHRs can be shared with other organizations involved in a patient’s care if the computer systems are set up to talk to each other. Information in these records should only be shared for purposes authorized by law or by the patient. Patients have privacy rights whether their information is stored as a paper record or stored in an electronic form. The same federal laws that already protect their health information also apply to information in EHRs.

members and friends. The HIPAA Privacy Rule ensures that patients have rights over their health information, including the right to get their information, make sure it’s correct, and know who has seen it.

What Happens if a Patient Wants to Share Health Information with a Family Member or a Friend?

HIPAA requires most doctors, nurses, hospitals, nursing homes, and other healthcare providers to protect the privacy of a patient’s health information. However, if they don’t object, a healthcare provider or health plan may share relevant information with family members or friends involved in their healthcare or payment for their healthcare in certain circumstances.

When Health Information Can be Shared

Under HIPAA, a patient’s healthcare provider may share their information face-to-face, over the phone, or in writing. A healthcare provider or health plan may share relevant information if:

A patient gives their provider or plan permission to share their information.

A patient is present and does not object to sharing the information.

A patient is not present, and the provider determines based on professional judgment that it’s in their best interest.

Examples:

An emergency room doctor may discuss their treatment in front of their friend when the patient asks the friend to come into the treatment room.

The hospital may discuss a patient’s bill with a patient’s daughter who is with them and has a question about the charges, if you do not object.

A doctor may discuss the drugs a patient needs to take with their health aide who has come with them to their appointment.

A nurse may not discuss a patient’s condition with their brother if they tell her not to.

HIPAA also allows healthcare providers to give prescription drugs, medical supplies, x-rays, and other healthcare items to a family member, friend, or other person a patient sends to pick them up.

A healthcare provider or health plan may also share relevant information if a patient is not around or cannot give permission when a healthcare provider or plan representative believes, based on professional judgment, that sharing the information is in the patient’s best interest.

Examples:

A patient had emergency surgery and is still unconscious. The surgeon may tell the patient’s spouse about their condition, either in person or by phone, while they are unconscious.

A doctor may discuss a patient’s drugs with their caregiver who calls their doctor with a question about the right dosage.

A doctor may not tell a patient’s friend about a past medical problem that is unrelated to their current condition.

Consent in Healthcare and Research

Historical overview

A close-up of a test tube containing a model of a double helix.

One of the earliest ethics codes was the Nuremberg Code—a set of 10 principles written in 1947 in conjunction with the trials of Nazi physicians accused of shockingly cruel research on concentration camp prisoners during World War II. It provided a standard against which to compare the behavior of the individuals on trial—many of whom were eventually convicted and either imprisoned or sentenced to death. The Nuremberg Code was particularly clear about the importance of carefully weighing risks against benefits and the need for informed consent.

The Declaration of Helsinki is a similar ethics code that was created by the World Medical Council in 1964. Among the standards that it added to the Nuremberg Code was that research with human participants should be based on a written protocol—a detailed description of the research—that is reviewed by an independent committee. The Declaration of Helsinki has been revised several times, most recently in 2013.

In the United States, concerns about the Tuskegee study and others led to the publication in 1978 of a set of federal guidelines called the Belmont Report. The Belmont Report explicitly recognized the principle of seeking justice, including the importance of conducting research in a way that distributes risks and benefits fairly across different groups at the societal level. The Belmont Report was influential in the formation of national ethical guidelines for research in both the US and Canada.

Informed consent

Informed consent means obtaining and documenting people’s agreement to have a medical procedure or participate in a study, having informed them of everything that might reasonably be expected to affect their decision. Properly informing participants includes details of the procedure, the risks and benefits of the research, the fact that they have the right to decline to participate or to withdraw from the study, the consequences of doing so, and any legal limits to confidentiality.

Although the process of obtaining informed consent often involves having participants read and sign a consent form, it is important to understand that this written agreement is not all it is. Although having participants read and sign a consent form might be enough when they are competent adults with the necessary ability and motivation, many participants do not actually read consent forms or read them but do not understand them. For example, participants often mistake consent forms for legal documents and mistakenly believe that by signing them they give up their right to sue the healthcare provider or researcher (Mann, 1994). Even with competent adults, therefore, it is good practice to tell participants about the risks and benefits, demonstrate the procedure, ask them if they have questions, and remind them of their right to withdraw at any time—in addition to having them read and sign a consent form.

Note also that there are situations in which informed consent is not necessary. These include situations in which the research is not expected to cause any harm and the procedure is straightforward or the study is conducted in the context of people’s ordinary activities. For example, if you wanted to sit outside a public building and observe whether people hold the door open for people behind them, you would not need to obtain their informed consent. Similarly, if a professor wanted to compare two legitimate teaching methods across two sections of her research methods course, she would not need to obtain informed consent from her students unless she planned to publish the results in a scientific journal about learning.

Key Takeaways

A complex ethical challenge involving stakeholders with competing moral claims frequently demands consideration of a variety of ethical principles and theories to address the situation and justify a proposed intervention.

Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), gives patients rights over their health information, including the right to get a copy of their information, make sure it is correct, and know who has seen it.

Even with competent adults, therefore, it is good practice to tell participants about the risks and benefits, demonstrate the procedure, ask them if they have questions, and remind them of their right to withdraw at any time—in addition to having them read and sign a consent form.

Vocabulary

Autonomy – Self-legislating; enacts from within the moral rules and principles that bind the will and guide action

Categorical Imperative – An unconditional requirement for an action to be moral

Declaration of Helsinki – Added to the Nuremberg Code that research with human participants should be based on a written protocol that is reviewed by an independent committee

Deontology – An ethical theory that focuses on the rules governing action

Ethical Framework – A tool or approach for practically addressing ethical challenges that often includes a stepwise procedure

Electronic Health Records (EHRs) – Electronic version of a patient’s medical history and other information about their health

Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) – A federal law that gives patients rights over their health information

Informed Consent – Obtaining and documenting people’s agreement to have a medical procedure or participate in a study, having informed them of everything that might reasonably be expected to affect their decision

Morality – A society’s shared, stable beliefs about what is good and bad, right and wrong

Nuremberg Code – One of the earliest ethics codes; contained 10 principles for human research, including the importance of weighing risks against benefits and the need for informed consent

Principles – General categories, rules, or guidelines that form the basis of a discipline

Utilitarianism – An ethical theory that focuses on the result of an action

Virtue Ethics – An ethical theory that focuses on the moral character of the actor or agent

good luck!