Grading is a Scam (and Motivation is a Myth) | A Professor Explains
Log in
YouTube
by
jaja109
This is Maria.
She had always been a curious girl, asking her parents questions about everything around
her.
When she got to school, she did the same thing with her teachers.
But...she found that they didn't like it very much when she asked too many questions.
Other students, who were quiet, got gold stars and little tickets they could turn in at the
end of the week for a toy or a piece of candy. But Maria didn't get those, and she felt left
out when the other kids would play with their prizes.
So...she learned to be quiet. She stopped asking questions. She kept her eyes focused
on her work. She was a good student. And, eventually, she got her gold star.
She kept this up throughout her school years, and she learned that she could get more than
just gold stars and candy in exchange for her silence. If she got an A on a test, her
parents would give her $10. If she got straight A's all year, they'd give her a hundred. If
she could get a 4.0 GPA for her whole high school career, the local college would give
her thousands.
What was that worth to Maria, a girl who'd been told over and over by her parents and
teachers and coaches that a college education was what you needed to get out of your hometown,
get a job, and "really make it"?
Well, she did what it took to get those grades. She studied and did her homework, of course.
But she also had to be smart about things-she had to prioritize. She quit the band during
her sophomore year so she could fit another AP class into her schedule. She chose the
projects that looked the easiest, because she couldn't risk screwing up and jeopardizing
her grades. She worried herself sick-literally sick-before every exam, because every exam,
every project, every paper, every quiz, everything was "make-or-break."
Because Maria worked so hard on her grades, they started to define her; her entire sense
of self-worth was based on her GPA. The A's were nice, of course, but they felt unearned-after
all, she'd crammed for them; she didn't feel like she'd actually learned anything. And
anything lower than an A was a sign of personal failure and worthlessness and represented
a hole nearly impossible to climb out of.
Everything was a calculation. Everything was a decision. Everything was based on "What
is my teacher looking for? What is the right answer, and what is the path of least resistance
that'll get me there?"
For Maria, the purpose of school was to figure out what your teacher wanted, and then give
that to them. Teachers held grades over students' heads like pinatas...or guillotines. Give
the teacher what they want, tell them what they want to hear, turn your work in on time,
sit down and be quiet... Or else...
That little girl who had asked all those questions - who had approached life with curiosity and
passion - was gone. In her place was an anxious teenager who saw school as a barrier to her
future - or just a means to an end - and who'd missed all the learning that was supposed