HS1101 U1: Healthcare Ethics During a Pandemic

( Healthcare Ethics During a Pandemic )

______________________________________

As clinicians and support personnel struggle with their responsibilities to treat during the current COVID-19 pandemic, several ethical issues have emerged. Will healthcare workers and support staff

fulfill their duty to treat in the face of high risks? Will institutional and government leaders at all levels do the right things to help alleviate healthcare workers risks and fears? Will physicians be willing to

make hard, resource-allocation decisions if they cannot first husband or improvise alternatives? With our healthcare facilities and governments unprepared for this inevitable disaster, front-line

doctors, advanced providers, nurses, EMS, and support personnel struggle with acute shortages of equipment—both to treat patients and protect themselves. With their personal and possibly their

family’s lives and health at risk, they must weigh the option of continuing to work or retreat to safety. This decision, made daily, is based on professional and personal values, how they perceive existing risks—including available protective measures, and their perception of the level and transparency

of information they receive. Often, while clinicians get this information, support personnel do not, leading to absenteeism and deteriorating healthcare services. Leadership can use good risk

communication (complete, widely transmitted, and transparent) to align healthcare workers’ risk perceptions with reality. They also can address the common problems healthcare workers must

overcome to continue working (ie, risk mitigation techniques). Physicians, if they cannot sufficiently husband or improvise lifesaving resources, will have to face difficult triage decisions. Ideally, they will

use a predetermined plan, probably based on the principles of Utilitarianism (maximizing the greatest good) and derived from professional and community input. Unfortunately, none of these plans is

optimal. [West J Emerg Med.2020;21(3)477–483.]

______________________________________

Disclaimer: Due to the rapidly evolving nature of this outbreak, and in the interests of rapid dissemination of reliable, actionable information, this paper went through expedited peer review. Additionally, information should be considered current only at the time of publication and may evolve as the science develops.

( INTRODUCTION )

Disasters recur on a regular basis. In any disaster, and especially in those caused by disease, the public expects healthcare professionals to be on the front lines. Indeed, most healthcare professionals expect that of themselves and their

colleagues. In most disasters, and certainly during the current COVID-19 pandemic, frontline healthcare professionals face

two key ethical issues: (1) whether to respond despite the risks involved; and (2) how to distribute scarce, lifesaving medical resources. In this paper, I discuss how healthcare professionals weigh risk factors related to their response and the actions the healthcare community can take, including proper communication and mitigating responder concerns, to maximize

and maintain our caregiver workforce. I then very briefly discuss the ethics of scarce resources and suggest options, such as recalling retired clinicians to service, improvisation, and husbanding available resources to mitigate rationing.

(ETHICAL ASPECTS OF THE CURRENT PANDEMIC)

As COVID-19 devastates the world, bringing another feared and inevitable highly infectious pandemic to the current generation of healthcare professionals, we face a slew of ethical dilemmas. Some of our colleagues around the globe reportedly

have already had to make resource allocation decisions about which patients to treat. Others have had to struggle to provide

lesser degrees of (“degraded”) care. We have little direct control over these situations. Most of the world failed to recognize the existential threat of this new coronavirus early enough to fully prepare institutional, local, regional, national, and international

mobilization and response. Political expediency, hubris, scientifically ignorant leaders, and incomplete information led

to this inadequate advance planning by minimizing the threat when it appeared, further delaying vital public health action.

At this point, the most vital ethical decision in our war against an unseen enemy is the one over which each of us has direct control: Will we stay to help in the fight?

Most disaster plans depend on physicians, nurses, support staff, and prehospital personnel to maintain healthcare’s frontlines during crises. Yet planners cannot automatically assume that all healthcare workers will respond. Will our hospitals and clinics have enough physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, technicians, maintenance, and administrative staff to keep the doors open, the computers running, the linens clean, the lights on, and the facilities safe? Will our 9-1-1 systems still be able to dispatch medics, firefighters, and police? That depends on the iterative, possibly hourly or daily, decisions that each affected individual repeatedly makes.

Such decisions are not purely ethical, but rather are complex determinations based on religious and personal values, family and community responsibilities, health and financial stability, and risk assessment. In 2001, for example, the AMA Code of Ethics was modified from “solemnly commit[ing] ourselves to apply our knowledge and skills when needed, though doing so may put us at risk”1 to “physicians should balance immediate benefits to individual patients with ability to care for patients in the future.”2 The American College of Emergency Physicians, meanwhile, stated in its 2017 Code of Ethics for Emergency Physicians: ‘‘Courage is the ability to carry out one’s obligations despite personal risk or danger.

Emergency physicians exhibit courage when they assume personal risk to provide steadfast care for all emergency patients, including those who are agitated, violent, infectious, and the like.”3 Despite these professional ethical codes, nothing— either morally or legally—compels a response to risk-prone situations. Other than military personnel, no one is required to respond to potentially life-threatening emergencies. Professional oaths and codes may serve to guide practitioners, but they are not absolutes. The factors that guide people to respond are very personal; healthcare workers’ individual behavior and that of our organizational, professional and political leadership can modify those factors to increase the number that are willing to respond.4

(VALUES)

The moral backbone of medical professionals—a duty to put the needs of patients first—may be tested as they determine whether to stay and carry out their professional roles or to step back and decrease their own personal risks. Whether

providers will stay depends on their own risk assessment and value system. The “duty to treat” when one’s health, life, or personal well-being is threatened is not absolute. In a risk-prone situation, each of us will prioritize our personal and professional values, those traits in ourselves that we consider to be our fundamental driving forces. “Most clinicians first assess the risks to our own and to our family’s life, health, and safety. We may then factor in, to varying degrees, our religious beliefs and personal motivations, all colored by elements of our personality. Next, we may consider professional factors, including the

precepts in our healthcare profession’s oaths and codes, as well as other ethical and

religious dicta to which we subscribe.

Most clinicians will focus on their concrete professional responsibilities.”5

These professional factors include:

• Supporting/assuming the same risk as colleagues

• Collegial pressure/consequences of not helping

• Augmenting community welfare

• Fulfilling public expectation and trust

• Using societally underwritten special training and professional status

• Fulfilling implied consent to help those in need (social contract)

Emergency physicians may also feel that in these situations they are compelled to use their special knowledge about triage, allocation of scarce resources (eg, vaccines,

prophylactic or treatment medications, or intensive care unit [ICU] ventilators), public health mandates (eg, isolation or quarantine, or mandatory vaccination), and the use of altered standards of care.4,6

(RISK ASSESSMENT AND MITIGATION)

Risk Assessment

When preparing for a disaster, planners should consider not how they expect people to respond, but rather why they are

likely to respond. 7 The risks to physicians and other healthcare providers’ will vary by the nature of the causative agent, the

provider’s activities and underlying health, and the protections offered and used. People decide which risks to accept or to avoid based on their own perceptions of the source and quality of the information they receive.8,9 Quick, emotional impressions

often precede and guide ‘‘rational’’ risk appraisals.10 Provider and population perception of their risk from COVID-19 will probably not be congruent with reality. In part, this will be due to the discordant messages from many senior politicians and other officials, but also will be influenced by the real- time updates in scientific knowledge about the disease, its transmission, and possible protective measures.

Risk Communication and Mitigation

In crises, individuals must balance good information from valid media, government, and other sources to help identify the actual risks to themselves and their loved ones. Providing the best current information about the risks as well as the opportunities to assist during a crisis will help healthcare

professionals make defensible decisions in disaster settings.5 Transparent and consistent information generates the trust

necessary for both caregivers and the population to develop a reasonable risk assessment during conditions of uncertainty.11 Issuing incomplete or conflicting information, as was done

during the first months of the COVID-19 outbreak, caused many providers to make decisions to respond based on heated

emotions and inaccurate risk perceptions. People have been shown to naturally exaggerate the risk of phenomena that are

unknown or “dreaded,” such as those with delayed, irreversible or manmade effects; those that have new, unknown, or unobservable risks; those that are global; and those that are “hyped” by the media.5

Historical precedent and the nature of the medical profession demonstrate that we will have enough physicians and, probably, nurses to treat patients. Other professional and non-professional staff needed to keep healthcare institutions operating may not be as willing to risk themselves. Recent

history suggests that we probably will not have enough support personnel because, although they may be at as much or more

risk than healthcare professionals, their personal safety is often considered as an afterthought by administrators. “An important lesson from the SARS outbreak is that, whereas most clinicians will ‘‘stay and fight,’’ vital support personnel, including those in materials and supply, logistics, cleaning, information technology communications, maintenance, and refuse removal, may feel no commitment to assist; moreover, they may feel undervalued, unprotected from risks, and ignored when they are omitted from vital communications.”12 If all the staff necessary to run medical facilities fail to receive timely, relevant and believable information, they may not respond, and the quality of available healthcare will deteriorate. Widely distributing accurate risk assessments and descriptions of protective measures for staff will encourage the maximal number of clinicians and other necessary personnel to respond to the situation. Therefore, disaster planners and managers should do everything possible to communicate the risks clearly to all members of the healthcare system and to provide them with as much support and security as possible.

Risk communication (Figure 1) is “the exchange of real-time information, advice and opinions between experts and people facing threats to their health, economic or social well-being.” 13 Its purpose “is to enable people at risk to

1. Be First: Quickly sharing information about a disease outbreak can help stop the spread of disease, and prevent and reduce illness and even death. People often remember the first information they receive should come from health

experts.

• Even if the cause of the outbreak or specific disease is unknown, share facts that are available. This can help you stay ahead of possible rumors.

• Share information about the signs and symptoms of disease, who is at risk, treatment and care options, and when to seek medical care.

2. Be Right: Accuracy establishes credibility. Information should include what is known, what is not known, and what is being done to fill in the information gaps.

• Public health messages and medical guidance must complement each other. For example, public health officials should not widely encourage people to go to the doctors if doctors are turning people away and running out of medicine for critically ill people.

• Always fact check with subject-matter experts. One incorrect message can cause harmful behaviors and may result in people losing trust in future messages.

3. Be Credible: Honesty, timeliness, and scientific evidence encourage the public to trust your information and guidance. Acknowledge when you do not have enough information to answer a question and then work with the appropriate experts

to get an answer.

• Do not make promises about anything that is not yet certain, such as distribution of vaccines or mediciations without confirmed availability.

• Clinicians should be present at press or community events to answer medical questions.

4. Express Empathy: Disease outbreaks can cause fear and disrupt daily lives. Lesser-known or emerging diseases casue more uncertainty and anxiety. Acknowledging what people are feeling and their challenges shows that you are considering their perspectives when you give recommendations.

• For example, during a telebriefing for the coronavirus disease 2019 response: “Being quarantined can be disruptive, frustrating, and feel scary. Especially when the reason for quarantine is exposure to a new disease

for which there may be limited information.”

5. Promote Action: In an infectious disease outbreak, public understanding of and action on disease prevention is key to stopping the spread.

• Keep action messages simple, short, and easy to remember, like “cover your cough.”

• Promote action messages in different ways to make sure they reach those with disabilities, limited English proficiency, and varying access to information.

6. Show Respect: Respectful communication is particularly important when people feel vulnerable. Respectful communication promotes cooperation and rapport. Actively

listen to the issues and solutions brought up by local communities and local leadership.

• Acknowledge different cultural beliefs and practices about diseases, and work with communities to adapt behaviors and promote understanding.

• Do not dismiss fears or concerns. Give people a chance to talk and ask questions.

make informed decisions to protect themselves and their loved ones.”13 Risk communication can help keep healthcare

and other vital workers at their posts. But it must be done by appropriate people, educated in risk-communication techniques, in a trustworthy manner (honestly, frequently,

open/available), and through easily accessible means, which includes role-modeling by those in charge.14 In addition to providing information, research shows

that to attain the maximal response during risk-prone and other disasters, planners must do everything practicable to

mitigate perceived risks and to address other concerns that may prevent staff from being either able or willing to work

in a disaster (Table 1). To address one concern, on March 20, 2020, the American Academy of Emergency Medicine issued a position statement saying, in part, that they believe

“a physician, nurse, PA, first responder or other healthcare professional has the right to be removed from the schedule of work requiring direct contact with patients potentially infected with COVID-19 for issues of personal health, such as being on immunosuppressive therapy or other similar concerns, without the risk of termination of employment.”15 Rarely discussed, but a key part of maintaining our workforce, is to support the psychosocial needs of the healthcare team. According to medical anthropologist Monica Schoch-Spana, “Pandemics aren’t just physical. They bring

with them an almost shadow pandemic of psychological and societal injuries as well.”17 Psychosocial support for healthcare

workers in the current war against COVID-19 will be akin to post-traumatic stress disorder treatment for soldiers manning the front lines for extended periods. People respond to the

Risk to/safety of responder

• Actions to help protect responder: priority for vaccinations, priority for prophylactic/treatment

medications, appropriate/sufficient PPE, and prespecified responder decontamination procedures

• Clear, continuous, consistent, honest, and transparent communication to all responders

• Continuously available (and updatated as necessary) disaster plan

• Knowledgeable individuals available to answer any workplace safety questions

Risk to/safety of responder’s family and loved ones

• Actions to help protect family: priority for vaccinations, priority for prophylactic/treatment

medications, decontaminating responder, and providing PPE at home

• Clear, proactive, consistent, honest, transparent, and ongoing communication from employer to responder’s family

• Continuously available (and updated as necessary) disaster plan

• Knowledgeable individuals available to answer any questions about responder and family safety

Child and elder care

• Provide paid sitters or care at health care facility

• Arrange, in advance, for local governments to keep schools open, whenever possible

Risk to/safety of responder’s pets

• Provide or pay for pet care Trust/confidence in health care

organization/leadership

• Have and communicate to all employees an all-hazard disaster plan, including risk-reduction

measures, that is easily accessible, practiced, and modified as necessary based on circumstances

• Maintain clear, continuous, consistent, honest, and transparent communication to all responders about current disaster knowledge and plan

• Overtly and continuously demonstrate duty to protect and support responders

Inadequate disaster-related Human Resource policies30

• Provide life/disability insurance and liability/legal protection for duration of disaster response

• Responders may leave work as necessary

• Flexible work hours

• Clear return-to-work policies

• Provide responders with communication (if possible) to their families

Adequate reimbursement for time

and activities

• Guaranteed appropriate pay/comp time/bonus pay for level of their activities

Safe, guaranteed transportation • Private vans or rooms and board at health care facility

• Arrange, in advance, for local governments to keep mass transit systems running, whenever possible

Mandatory quarantine

• Clear, consistent, and reasonable quarntine policy

Personal illness/PTSD

• Guaranteed treatment for disaster-

acquired medical/psychiatric problems

Job requirements

• Effort to make all responders feel they are valued part of the disaster response

• Clear description of any modified job expectations/requirements during disaster

risks differently, so experienced professionals will need to

intervene before tragic, adverse events occur.

(SCARCE RESOURCES AND SOME SOLUTIONS)

In the current pandemic, some key resources are and will increasingly become scarce. Physicians will need to consider

how to distribute available resources and obtain or improvise others. The most ethical course of action is to do everything

possible to delay having to ration. Vital materials already in short supply include viral test kits and their associated

equipment and reagents, personal protective equipment (PPE),

ventilators, and hospital – especially ICU – beds. While China rapidly erected new, prefabricated hospitals to treat patients and

many countries around the world are establishing alternative

care sites, the United States has been slow to act.

Often not considered, healthcare workers, especially those with expertise treating the critically ill, will inevitably become

a scarce resource. However, as the situation changes, most healthcare workers will constantly reassess their decisions

about responding. As increasing numbers of personnel get sidelined due to actual or suspected disease, exhaustion, or

fear for themselves or their families. Some active and retired personnel who initially stayed out of the fight or were sidelined

due to illness or other circumstances may reassess their decision and join the battle. Employing senior medical students and

extending advance practitioners’ scope of practice has been suggested as one way to ameliorate this problem.

In England and Wales, the National Health Service has asked about 65,000 retired doctors and nurses to return to work.

In Scotland, they are recalling those who retired within the past three years. If these clinicians have been away from practice

for more than a short time, they will receive brief refresher training.26 The Institute of Medicine, among others, have

described how to best manage resource scarcity in a widespread

disaster (Table 2). Many of these strategies are discussed in more detail elsewhere. 27

(ETHICS OF SCARCE RESOURCE ALLOCATION)

During or after attempts at conservation, reutilization, adaption, and substitution are performed maximally, rationing will need to be implemented.31 The ethical principle that guides rationing is distributive justice, which requires that scarce resources be distributed fairly, providing them to those most

in need. Specifically, it requires impartial and neutral decision makers to consistently apply rationing decisions across people

and time (treating like cases alike).32 This is based on Utilitarian principles, including conservation of resources, fiduciary responsibility (stewardship), multiplier effect (does the person have a job that will save other lives?), immediate usefulness,

medical success, and caretaker role.33,34 Most ethicists agree, however, that such distribution should be equitable, although

in some circumstances other distribution methods, such as first come, first served; equal distribution; and even, no distribution

may be more rational. Even with agreement about equitable distribution, scarcity often requires clinicians to prioritize which

patients receive the resources.33,34

As the COVID-19 pandemic extends its devastation, physicians around the world are already facing the daunting task of rationing lifesaving resources. This is upending their

traditional method of treating the sickest first in emergency departments or “first come first served” in the ICUs.31 In Italy,

physicians have reported limiting ventilators to those less than 60 years old, and China and Spain have implemented medical

resource rationing. The US government and many states that have developed rationing plans have yet to explicitly implement

them.35 Many of these plans may be outdated, and none have been tested to determine whether they will save lives. In fact, a Canadian study of H1N1 patients found that 70% of patients that a rationing plan would have removed from ventilators

survived with continued ventilation.36

Dr. Laura Evans, an intensivist at the University of Washington, is working with her state to devise a triage plan

that would be doing “the most good for the most people and be fair and equitable and transparent in the process.” Yet

the Washington State Health Department recently issued a statement that “triage teams under crisis conditions should

consider transferring patients out of the hospital or to palliative care if the patient’s baseline functioning was marked

by ‘loss of reserves in energy, physical ability, cognition and general health.’”36

Rationing plans must conform to general ethical principles and to existing community moral standards. Community input

into these plans is vital for maintaining the public’s trust in

Table 2. Strategies for Scarce Resource Situations.27-30

Prepare—e.g., anticipate challenges, develop plans, stockpile materials. Identify leaders who can source or develop alternative supplies and equipment. Identify and train risk communicators. Plan to mitigate personnel difficulties in responding.

• Conserve—implement conservation strategies for supplies in shortage or anticipated shortage to ensure the minimum

impact/compromise possible (e.g., determining “at-risk” groups with priority for therapies in shortage and overall

strategies to conserve use of oxygen delivery devices [i.e., ventilators] or PPE.

• Substitute—provide an equivalent or near-equivalent medication or delivery device.

• Adapt—use of equipment for alternative purposes (e.g., anesthesia machine as ventilator)

• Re-use—plan to re-use a wide variety of materials after appropriate disinfection or sterilization (e.g., may include

oxygen delivery devices).

• Re-allocate—if no alternatives exist, remove a resource from one area/patient and allocate to another who has a higher likelihood of benefit (i.e., greater chance of surviving or more post-disease years to live).

clinicians, the institutions, and theorganizations involved in disaster relief and resource allocation. A major ethical

dilemma is that current rationing criteria may skew away from normally disadvantaged populations. In the past, allocation

plans were developed by the healthcare community. In the current crisis, some planning groups have tried to address this

by asking disparate communities throughout their region to offer input into the plans. 36

In all circumstances, rationing scarce medical resources is difficult and stressful. Such distribution, rather than being based

on politics, money or power, must be based on an equitable (fair), openly available, pre-existing plan. It may be beneficial to have emergency physicians and intensivists take the lead (under set protocols) in making these decisions, since they have had more experience than others in doing this on a regular basis.

Ideally, they will have support from their institutions’ bioethics consultants, social workers, and chaplains. Rationing will not end when medications to treat COVID-19 are eventually identified or vaccines are produced for prevention. In the first weeks or months there will be limited amounts available, with massive public anguish over

how they are being distributed. Those involved in developing and implementing healthcare resource distribution will need

to think ahead and include this eventuality in their plans. Lastly, resource allocation is not the only option. Disasters are the exact situations where clinicians and administrators need to “think outside the box” by expanding clinical roles and

responsibilities, relaxing restrictive regulations, improvising medical equipment, and devising other solutions to scarcity.27

Until the pandemic ends, we will need to encourage our healthcare workforce to stay at their posts and to use their fortitude and intellect as they face the multiple challenges

involved with their jobs.

CONCLUSION

• Physicians and other healthcare providers’ individual risks will vary by the nature of the causative agent,

the provider’s activities and underlying health, and the protections offered and used.

• Provider and population perception of risk will probably not be congruent with reality.

• History and the nature of the healthcare professions demonstrate that we will have enough professional personnel to treat patients.

• History suggests that we will not have the necessary support personnel—unless we respect their jobs and their risks and communicate with them in an open and

honest manner.

• The distribution of scarce, lifesaving resources will first require searching for alternatives and then making

triage decisions based on careful planning with, if possible, widespread input.