HS1101-U3: Evaluating Sources
Taking a minute to investigate the source before reading will help you decide if it is worth your time, and if it is, help you to better understand its significance and trustworthiness.
FIND Trusted Coverage: Sometimes you might not be concerned about the source as much as the claim being made. You want to know if it is true or false. You want to know if it represents a consensus viewpoint, or if it is the subject of much disagreement. In this case, your best strategy may be to ignore the source you had initially found and look for trusted reporting or analysis on the claim. If you get an article that says koalas have just been declared extinct from the Save the Koalas Foundation, your best bet might be not to investigate the source but to find the best source you can on this topic, or, just as importantly, to scan multiple sources and see what, the expert consensus seems to be. In other words, find other coverage that better suits your needs — more trusted, more in-depth, etc.Do you have to agree with the consensus once you find it? Not necessarily. Still, understanding the context and history of a claim will help you better evaluate it and better define your starting point for future investigation.
TRACE Claims, Quotes, and Media Back to the Original Context: Much of what we find on the internet has been stripped of context. Maybe there is a video of a fight between two people with Person A as the aggressor. But what happened before that? What was clipped out of the video and what stayed in? Maybe there is a picture that seems real but the caption could be misleading. Maybe a claim is made about a new medical treatment based on a research finding, but you are not sure if the cited research paper really said that. In these cases, you will have you trace the claim, quote, or media back to the source, so you can see it in its original context and ascertain if the version you saw was accurately presented.
It’s All About Restoring Context
As you can see, there is a theme that runs through all of these moves: they are about reconstructing the necessary context to read, view, or listen to digital content effectively.
One piece of context is who the speaker or publisher is. What’s their expertise? What’s their agenda? What’s their record of fairness or accuracy? When you hear a rumor, you want to know who the source is before reacting. Investigate web sources in the same way.
When it comes to claims, a key piece of context includes whether they are broadly accepted or rejected or something in between. By scanning for other coverage, you can see what the expert consensus is, learn the history around it, and ultimately find a better source.
Finally, when evidence is presented with a certain frame — whether a quote or a video or a scientific finding — sometimes it helps to reconstruct the original context in which the photo was taken or the research claim was made. It can look quite different in context!
In some cases, these techniques will show you that certain claims are outright wrong or that some sources are “bad actors” trying to deceive you. But in the vast majority of cases, they do something just as important: they reestablish the context that the web so often strips away, allowing for more fruitful engagement with all digital information.