Introduction to Modern Philosophy: The Emergence of Rationalism

With medieval philosophy covered, it’s time to examine the next big paradigm shift in
philosophy. The 15th century Renaissance marked the end of the medieval era and
signaled a revival of ancient Greek knowledge and values. Copernicus revolutionized astronomy
by removing Earth from the center of the universe to propose a heliocentric and more mathematically
accurate model, thereby greatly influencing the Scientific Revolution to come. Likewise, the
“Divine” was taken out of the center of discussion in philosophy and the sciences to shift the focus
onto human beings in a natural world. Though by no means atheistic, as many authors would emphasize
their faith in some way, this period diverted to a secular discussion in a naturalistic perspective.
In philosophy, this shift was characterized by two main schools of thought: the rationalists,
focusing on reason itself and its faculties above the senses and experience, and the empiricists,
who, though not discarding reason entirely, focused on experience and that which is attained
by the senses, above a strong conception of rationality. This contrast was similar to the
already age-old distinction between Platonic and Aristotelian conceptions of the world.
Both schools were followed by the idealists, who tried to resolve this duality in different
manners. We’ll begin with the rationalists here, then move on to the empiricists, and then follow
up with the idealists. Finally, we’ll talk about political philosophers, and then conclude this
section on modern philosophy by catching up on the logical developments in this period,
before then advancing to contemporary philosophy in the early 20th century.
Interestingly, the first philosopher we will talk about does not fit any of these labels. Michel
de Montaigne was a curious figure in the 16th century who created the “essay” format as we know
it today in literature, also reviving Pyrrhonism in modern philosophy, and being one of the first
examples of the limitless manner of philosophical investigation that the modern times allowed. He
wrote an abundance of texts, all guided only by a frank desire to understand human nature,
education, and the world, through his own reason. They were so forthright that he frequently changes
positions on multiple topics throughout his life, and thus he always remarked that as his own senses
and memory are faulty, so are everyone’s. Therefore no human being could ever achieve
true knowledge of anything. His essays were deeply affected by the expeditions to America being made
at the time. Reports were given from voyagers regarding a “New World”, not only in a physical
sense, but also cultural, given the description of costumes and worldviews from natives. These shaped
Montaigne's views on culture and tolerance, and he refused to accept an ethnocentric approach in
which European culture was by any means superior from those that could be found in the “New World”.
He also wrote extensively against authority and organized religion,
as he judged the religious quarrels of his time beyond any resemblance of divinity, and thoroughly
criticized education of his time, which focused on supposed absolute knowledge of the teacher.
This prevented curiosity and questioning, and thus learning itself. Additionally, there was
the frequent use of abstract concepts distant from students’ everyday lives and experiences. Although
his ideas were not very relevant to future philosophy, being so varied and inconsistent,
his new method of writing and pedagogical insights are clearly very relevant to this day.
One of the first and most famous proper rationalists was René Descartes, a prominent