That Time Buffy Made Government Propaganda
Log in
YouTube
by
yuliababyak13
This video is brought to you by Curiositystream. Get access to
Curiositystream and my streaming service Nebula,
and watch my Nebula exclusive video Debater Theater at curiositystream.com/sarahz
Love is a very complicated thing. It’s often said that its opposite of hate is indifference;
you know, if you love something or if you hate it, it means you care about it on a very deep level,
either way. I think there’s probably some truth to this in general, but I think the principle
that most clearly and deeply demonstrates this maxim is my feelings on the television
show Buffy the Vampire Slayer. If you asked me to name my favourite show in the world,
despite everything, I don’t think I would hesitate for more than a second to name Buffy.
The characters live in my mind, all unique and memorable and (mostly) lovable, the writing is
funny and snappy but unlike a lot of later Whedon and Whedon-inspired work, rarely demonstrates its
humour at the expense of sincerity. Its stories are heartfelt and meaningful and despite how over
the top they can often be, they end up expressing the transition from adolescence to adulthood in
some of the more honest ways I’ve seen, especially for a fantasy show that came out a quarter century
ago. I watched the show for the first time when I was about Season 1 Buffy’s age, and rewatching it
now being actually older than Buffy ends up at the very end of the show, I end up finding new truths
in it, new stories that emotionally resonate with me in ways they didn’t initially, and a refreshed
way of viewing the narrative. From goofy over-the-top narratives like making all the middle-aged actors
pretend to be moody teenagers in Band Candy to the simple and very honest tragedy of an episode
like The Body to their musical episode which I will once again restate is probably the best
I’ve ever seen a single musical episode of a show ever done, Buffy is an amazing show. I love it.
At the same time, if you asked me to come up with a laundry list of my deepest grievances
with Buffy, I could go on for an incredibly long time. I can’t make promises, but one of these days
I hope to do just a full-scale video on the entire series, so I’ll reserve most of those until then,
but my point is that there’s a lot I would change, from things that aged poorly to things
that should’ve never been included in the show to begin with to things that are just dumb. At the
end of the day, though, my grievances with Buffy are not a manifestation of hating this show; they
are a manifestation of loving it and wanting to see it be the best it can be. And I think that’s
true for a large number of Buffy fans. I don’t think I’ve ever met a single one who didn’t have
a list of characters, episodes, or plot points that they would change around in a heartbeat
given the chance. And among that list, if you spend enough time in Buffy circles, you start
to see a few things repeatedly floated around. A few episodes people take grievance with for their
subject matter; that’s stuff like Seeing Red and Empty places, incredibly divisive characters like
Xander and universally hated ones like Kennedy, and that one child actor who I’m allowed to
bully because he’s probably like 40 now. This kid suuuuuuucks.
But with very little doubt, one particular episode tops the list in most discussion spaces. It’s
voted as the worst buffy episode over and over again in polls and listicles, it constantly
comes up on Reddit threads as the dumbest or worst made, and when you watch it… ehhh it’s
not exactly hard to see why. At the same time, there’s been somewhat of an effort over the years
to redeem it in the eyes of some detractors. You have people saying ‘hey, I watched this for the